Whether or not you are a superstitious type and believe in the power of numbers, it is unfortunately an undeniable fact that 13/11/13 will be a very unlucky day for Monsieur Hercule Wayne Poirot, in that this is the date that the fastidious little Belgian baldie will finally meet his maker on screen, with Curtain, the last of the four final episodes in the series airing on ITV that day.
Poirot has been played by other actors before, of course, and will no doubt be played by other actors again. But when one watches Albert Finney in Murder on the Orient Express, whilst he is an entertaining screen presence, one can never quite get over the idea that this is someone giving a "performance" (and a rather mannered, hammy one at that). With every grimace and comical facial expression, not to mention an accent so thick it could have been turned into Belgian pate, he seems to be saying "Eee, look at me, a big burly chuffer in his thirties from Salford playing some funny foreign bugger!" Peter Ustinov, meanwhile, did a wonderful Peter Ustinov impersonation in six movies and TV movies in the late 1970s and 1980s, two of which (Death on the Nile and Evil Under the Sun) probably outdid the Suchet versions - Death on the Nile because it was so melodramatic and co-starred Angela Lansbury as a sort of perenially pissed version of Jessica Fletcher, Evil Under the Sun because it was just so deliciously camp (yes Roddy McDowall, I am looking at you in particular!) But David Suchet IS, WAS and probably ALWAYS WILL BE Poirot for me and millions of others, precisely because it doesn't feel like he is "acting". He effortlessly inhabits the role and achieves the colossal feat of making the silly walk, the slightly obsessive compulsive habits and the preposterous facial hair genuinely feel like a real person (at least as real as cosy Sunday night ITV ever gets).
He will be a tough act to follow. I was amused by one particularly idiotic message thread on imdb entitled "Is it time for a modern, basass representation of Hercule Poirot" which strikes me as being a bit like asking whether it is time for a modern, badass representation of Winnie the Pooh. That just isn't how Poirot works. I am not quite sure why people are always trying to push characters in that particular direction. No-one is ever saying "isn't it time for a more middle aged, sedentary representation of James Bond?", although if they are I would refer them to Roger Moore in A View to A Kill - by the time Rog made that one he was so ancient that viewers are on tenterhooks about whether he will even survive the process of baking a quiche (something he genuinely does in that film) let alone hanging from the Golden Gate bridge by his fingertips!
Where this idea comes from can be summarised in one word...Sherlock! But modernising Sherlock Holmes works because:
(a) it worked last time they tried it, with Basil Rathbone furiously battling Nazis and deteriorating scripts in the 1940s and somehow coming up on top in spite of both - old Basil was clearly lacing every line with boredom and contempt by the end of that run of films but fortunately that was sufficiently in character that nobody really minded (he did, after all, have to contend with living with Nigel Bruce as Dr Watson, who essentially played him as Baker Street's answer to Homer Simpson).
On the other hand, the 2000 TV modernisation of Murder on the Orient Express (with Alfred Molina) didn't really work - they tried to water down Poirot's eccentricities (an approach the producers of Sherlock thankfully didn't repeat), which took away much of the magic of the character, and they even gave him a girlfriend, which is just wrong on so many levels! Some of the Ustinov ones were also "modernisations" but those basically felt like episodes of Columbo, and one of them even featured a young, moustache-less and only "mostly bald" David Suchet as...Inspector Japp (watching this kind of makes you feel like you've wandered into a parallel universe).
(b) Sherlock Holmes was always running around, hot on the heels of his various "nemeses" in the first place and using the most modern technology at his disposal, whether that was in the 1890s, the 1940s or the present day - that is part of the essence of his character.
But Poirot is a different beast - with one exception (in Hallowe'en Party) where he actually takes it upon himself to give the murderer an almighty thwack with his iconic walking stick, his method of solving crimes is pretty unvarying. The Poirot guide to solving crimes:
Step one - hang around in the background making cryptic comments, focussing on minor trivial details and generally looking smug while the police are doing all the legwork.
Step two - wait for your good friend Japp to arrest the wrong person before unmasking the real killer, just so as to ensure that you make a total fool out of one of your oldest mates, who has done you the favour of not only giving you unlimited access to the scene of the crime despite your having no official standing or connection to the police, but has also let Captain Hastings hang around as well even though all he ever does is stand around looking vaguely lost and making inane comments like "Well I'll be jiggered!" whilst getting in everyone's way.
Step three - gather all of the suspects together in one room. Actually modern technology would help Poirot in this respect as nowadays most of them would have skype, meaning that he would not have to go through the awkward and arduous process of setting up these "denouement meetings in the drawing room" which must have been a logistical nightmare back in the thirties! They never show this bit on TV, but I imagine the conversations must go something like this:
Poirot: Allo, is that Colonel Mustard? Hercule Poirot speaks.
Col Mustard: Don't you mean "this is Hercule Poirot here?"
Poirot: Oui. Poirot, he can never get the hang of the English.
Col Mustard: Doesn't explain why you keep referring to yourself in the third person though, does it? People speaking French don't do that! Anyway, how long have you been living in the country now? Twenty years? And I've heard you spout all sorts of complicated speeches during the course of the investigation naming all manner of obscure poisons, yet you don't seem to have learned simple words or phrases like "yes", "no", "good" and "my friend". Shape up, man!
Poirot: To return to the point, s'il vous plait! What are you doing next Tuesday evening, monsieur?
Col Mustard: Goin' huntin'! Thought I'd bag a few pigeon!
Poirot: Ah that, it is reassuringly stereotypical, but also most irritating! Tuesday is the only evening all of the other suspects are free.
Col Mustard: Did you just call me a suspect?
Poirot: Mais oui.
Col Mustard: You've got a nerve, I must say. May I ask what sort of an event you're organising?
Poirot: I am gathering all those concerned in the murder together in the same room so that I can unmask the true killer.
Col Mustard: You mean you know who did it?
Poirot: Oui.
Col Mustard: And you haven't told the police?
Poirot: Well..non, not yet. But Chief Inspector Japp, he will also be there at the meeting next Tuesday.
Col Mustard: Japp? He's still on the force? Even though he arrested the wrong person in every single one of the last forty cases he worked on?
Poirot: Ah, but monsieur, you forget, he is the only Chief Inspector in the whole of Scotland Yard, which means that he has to investigate every single murder which happens in England, no matter where in the country it happens. He is very overworked!
Col Mustard: Well, you may have a point there. But why do you need everyone to be there?
Poirot: So that I can go around everyone in turn and insinuate that they are the killer before revealing who the real murderer is.
Col Mustard: What, even the victim's closest relatives? Isn't that a bit insensitive?
Poirot: Hercule Poirot, he is very thorough!
Col Mustard: Well anyway, I can't do next Tuesday so you'll just have to sort something else out.
Poirot: But that is impossible! This is the only day I can get everyone together in the next two months. The killer may have struck again by then!
Col Mustard: Well why don't you just call the police, tell them to arrest the real killer and have done with it!
Poirot: But that is ridiculous! I have memorised the twenty minute speech! And English, it is not my first language!
Col Mustard: What if the real killer brings a gun and just shoots you while you're warming up?
Poirot: Yes, it is curious that this it has never yet happened. Usually people start off by laughing, then calling me mad, but always Poirot manages to extract a badly acted confession from them at the end!
Col Mustard: You're mad!
Poirot: Yes I think on this occasion it is particularly important that you attend, monsieur!
Col Mustard: Well I'm still not coming so you'll have to do it without me!
Poirot: Are you determined to spoil my fun, monsieur?
[Poirot hangs up in disgust]
Poirot: Merde!
It's a strange formula, but one that has worked extremely well over the last twenty four years, give or take a dodgy episode or two.
Suchet's version of Orient Express took itself far too seriously and seemed to think it was The Life of David Gale (for the record I am not in favour of the death penalty in real life, but I am vigorously in favour of dealing out death and justice to fictional villains, and found Suchet's anguished touchy-feely handwringing in that episode virtually unwatchable!)
The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, whilst enjoyable, was ultimately another disappointment just because it fell so far short of the novel. I was so impressed by the twist in that particular book that I had a go at turning it into a stage play myself when I was eleven or twelve, and whilst, when I look back on it, I will freely admit the result was in no way a great work of literature (Roger Ackroyd himself is written as talking like a pirate for absolutely no reason!) I think that even at that tender young age I did a better job of concealing the murderer's identity than the TV adaptation where it is blindingly bleeding obvious who the murderer is from about ten minutes in.
Ultimately I think that the series has lost a little of its magic in recent years, losing some of the fun of the early episodes (not to mention the iconic opening credits, which is truly unforgivable) and his gang of sidekicks. There have still been some fun moments, but for true classic Poirot I would particularly recommend the feature length episodes from the early to mid 1990s. Hickory Dickory Dock might be a good starting point for novices, demonstrating that Poirot had an inkling that something might be up with Sgt Nicholas Brody long before the CIA started getting suspicious. Other famous names who started off on Poirot include Emily Blunt, Michael Fassbender and a pair of future "Doctors" in Christopher Eccleston and Peter Capaldi - I mention this because I know that this blog has an avid American audience and was surprised to discover how into Doctor Who they are across the pond now (when visiting the fantastic Magic Castle in LA in August, the fact that Cary Grant, Orson Welles and Johnny Depp were or had all been members at some point was treated with an overwhelming sense of "meh" by its members but they were all terribly excited by the fact that Matt Smith had come visiting the night before).
The final series of Poirot has proved to be a mixed bag so far. Dead Man's Folly was great fun, a really classic episode with all sorts of funny goings on in the countryside. The Big Four was less successful despite bringing back Japp, Hastings and Miss Lemon, but that was mainly because it was based on what may have been Christie's second silliest book (the silliest being Passenger to Frankfurt - plot overview from wikipedia gives you a flavour:
"Suddenly, Stafford has unwittingly entered a web of international intrigue, from which the only escape is to outwit the power-crazed Countess von Waldsausen who is hell-bent on world domination through the manipulation and arming of the planet's youth, which brings with it what promises to be a resurgence of Nazi domination."
The Labours of Hercules was not bad bearing in mind that it was an attempt to condense a book of twelve short stories into one feature length episodes (they basically chucked out eight of them and cherry picked the best bits from the remaining four, meaning that the producers' claim to have adapted every Poirot story is not 100% accurate). I liked the Alpine location, shame they didn't give Simon Callow a bit more to do.
And what of Curtain, the very last episode of all, which sees Poirot, crippled with arthritis, pursuing a serial killer and forced to reexamine the strict moral code to which he has adhered for so long. Truth be told, I'm not quite sure I can watch it. I'm not quite ready to say farewell to my favourite (fictional) Belgian just yet.
I suspect however that the series will go out on a high - the presence of Life on Mars's Philip Glenister on the list of suspects is a promising sign. Having said that, even better would have been a series-crossover in which Gene "I once hit a bloke for speaking French" Hunt himself (instead of playing host to various 2000s interlopers in his police station) is himself transported back in time to the 1930s to team up with Poirot. I think they'd have got on. Heaven knows there aren't enough "Odd Couple buddy movies" out there!
Showing posts with label Albert finney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Albert finney. Show all posts
Sunday, 10 November 2013
Sunday, 28 October 2012
Review of Skyfall, or "You Only Live Thrice"
Perverse though it may sound, part of me actually wanted to dislike this film. Bearing in mind what a massive Bond fan I am, add this to the shameful dearth of decent Bond films over the last fifteen years, and the fact that such an opinion would have put me in the uncomfortable position of agreeing with the Guardian, you may think that I have gone slightly mad by making such an admission. But the truth is that I have always held some controversial views when it comes to the world's greatest spy. For example:
- Roger Moore is a bit of a legend;
- Sheriff J W Pepper in Live and Let Die is hilarious;
- Goldeneye (although easily the best of the Brosnan era) isn't nearly as good as everyone thinks it is;
- Never Say Never Again was the best Bond movie of the 1980s (for example look at this amazing video game sequence...unfortunately I think their estimate of how much Spain was worth was eerily prescient). This was in spite of the best efforts of a young Rowan Atkinson, who had clearly not yet finished his training at clown school when he made the film, to ruin the whole thing with his 2 minute cameo. Watch Sean Connery's face during their scenes together. He is clearly giving serious thought to the prospect of repeatedly clubbing the rubber faced young goon round the back of the head with a golf club; and
- A View to a Kill was the second best Bond movie of the 1980s, even though the quiche baking, Werthers Originals chewing Roger Moore was so creaky by the time he made it that he would have been thrown out of the Expendables (or, if I am being brutally honest, the cast of Last of the Summer Wine) for being too decrepit.
My reason for hoping to dislike the film was that having long had the ambition of dusting off/resuscitating my dormant blog with a review (or rather a series of loosely connected tangential ramblings cunningly disguised as a review...which I promise will remain more or less spoiler free) of Skyfall, I thought that having a controversial take on the film might increase my readership more than if I simply went with the flow of extremely positive reviews.
Besides, I did not want to be in the position of prematurely shooting my mouth off with fulsome praise and then changing my mind a few months down the line, as has so often happened to me in the past with Mr Bond. I vividly remember coming out of The World is Not Enough when I was fifteen and confidently declaring it the best Bond film ever made. But then again I think it is fair to say that back in those days I was not the sophisticated connisseur of cinema than I am today, as is evidenced by the fact that I went to see Will Smith's Wild Wild West (a film that I think is nowadays only shown in North Korean prisons as a form of torture) in the cinema...twice.
Unfortunately my view of the film, which for once I am pretty confident that I won't row back from on a second viewing, is disappointingly conventional, although I think that some of the more hyperbolic comments from journalists might be overegging the cake somewhat, having recently encountered articles with titles such as "Is this the best Bond film ever?" (no, although it's probably in the top 5), "Has Daniel Craig eclipsed Sean Connery as 007?" (no, but he's now a solid and comfortable second...sorry Rog, Pierce, Tim and....well, I don't think any apology to George is really necessary, at least not until he apologises to me for the quality of his performance) "Is Javier Bardem the best Bond villain ever?" (actually...he might be).
Skyfall is terrific, a high octane, witty, sophisticated blast from the pre-credits sequence to the very last scene (which the fans of "Classic Bond" will adore btw). The film opens in Istanbul, with a fantastic chase sequence complete with entertaining running commentary by Naomie Harris as Bond's fellow field agent Eve, who is communicating with M and co at MI6 HQ throughout the chase: "yes...007 is now chasing the assassin across the roofs of Istanbul with a motorbike...now he's ridden the motorbike off a bridge and onto the roof of a moving train (as one does)...yup, and now he's torn the train in half with a massive digger".
Then of course Bond is shot, marking the second time in the franchise's fifty year history that our hero is seemingly bumped off before the opening credits. This time, however, unlike in You Only Live Twice, he actually takes a bit of time to recover from what to most people would constitute quite a serious injury, amusing himself with bumming around in bars playing drinking games involving scorpions and watching Huw Edwards on the telly. You can tell he's supposed to be out of condition because he stops shaving, a state of affairs which persists for an unnerving amount of the film's hefty running time (come on man, you're James Bond, not Rab C Nesbitt).
Adele's "Skyfall" is a worthy addition to the canon of Bond's opening credit songs, even though it does seem to have been composed by Vitalstatistix the Gaul (special thanks are due to Shappi Khorsandi here, from whose cradle I snatched that joke before it was even twenty four hours old). After the drab excuses for music that we unfortunate viewers have been forced to endure in recent years (Madonna's Die Another Day is so ghastly that it could be used to curdle milk, while I can't even remember the theme to Quantum of Solace, as it was so instantly forgettable that I have managed to half persuade myself that it was in fact set to the theme tune for Dawn French's "Murder Most Horrid", with the words "Quantum of Solace" being substituted for "Murder Most Horrid", obviously), my expectations were not high, but it certainly holds its own with some of the classics of the Connery/Moore eras.
The plot is more focussed on MI6 and its personnel themselves than any of the films have been before, with Judi Dench, having come more and more into her own as M over the years with an increasingly meaty role in the proceedings as befits an actress of her status, taking centre stage as never before. This time the hitherto infallible spymistress is in deep trouble, having lost a hard drive with the names and secret identities of undercover agents around the world. Enquiries have been set up, and M is being urged to take early retirement by Mallory, who is played by a terrific Ralph Fiennes, mastering the admittedly somewhat predictable transition during the film from "stuffed shirt bureaucrat" to "a bit of a legend" (the one that pretty much all of Jack Bauer's bosses went through at some point during the series, usually over the course of a couple of hours) with characteristic aplomb - I especially enjoyed one particularly scathing putdown to Helen McCrory's smug, pen pushing minister, the smoothest and politest variation of "shut the f**k up" that I have heard for a long while. It has fallen into the hands of former agent turned full blown psycho Silva (Bardem, sporting a set of false teeth so disgusting that even my late grandfather would have been appalled), who has taken over a deserted island off the coast of Shanghai.
Silva means business, MI6 is blown up, Q branch (now run by a mellifluous voiced Ben Whishaw, channelling the spirit of Moss from the IT Crowd) is forced to relocate, and Bond sobers up and gets himself back on the case. Having a Q who is significantly younger than Bond is a new direction for the series, but it works, especially in the context of one of the film's core themes, namely "is there a place for old fashioned field agents like Bond in the 21st century world of sophisticated IT"...you may be able to guess what conclusion the film comes to on this. The first encounter between Bond and Q is extremely entertaining, with both Craig and Whishaw enjoying some nice one liners involving exploding pens and the like (you can tell the poor little lamb hasn't been working there very long in that he actually asks Bond to bring back his equipment undamaged...obviously the late Desmond Llewelyn's handover notes left something to be desired).
One liners, and wit in general, is something Skyfall has in spades, which is most welcome. I am not suggesting that the franchise should return to the double taking pigeon shenanigans of the Moore era, but after the gloomy, Bournesque tone of Casino Royale and Quantum of Solace, a lighter touch was clearly required. Sam Mendes and the writers clearly have a better sense of what Bond is than the franchise's creative teams have had for a while. Don't get me wrong, I liked Casino Royale and thought it was exactly the breath of fresh air that the franchise needed at the time (it's just a shame that it was followed up by the turgid blast of public lavatory stench that was Quantum of Solace). I just thought that it might have been nice if Craig cracked a smile every once in a while. He's not Jack Bauer, after all, dammit! Craig may be the first Bond since Connery who looks like he could actually handle himself in a fight, and I think it's no bad thing that he has chosen to emphasise the thuggish bruiser side of Bond rather than the debonair louche aspect that Moore and Brosnan chose to emphasise, but he can DO humour, albeit perhaps not quite as well as Sean or Roger. It's just than up until now, the writers haven't really let him.
But it's not just him. The film has unquestionably got the most talented cast ever gathered together for a Bond film (the possible exception being the original 1967 Casino Royale, which nevertheless ended up being one of the most garishly edited train wrecks ever committed to celluloid). Ironically though, it is not Craig, Bardem, Fiennes, Dench, Harris, Whishaw or Albert Finney who has the best line in the film, although all of them get at least a couple of zingers. No, for my money, the best line is saved up for a random old geezer watching Bond leap onto the back of a moving tube train during a particularly exhilarating chase sequence. "He's in a hurry to go home" he remarks to his wife.
And interestingly enough Bond does go home soon enough, taking his old Aston Martin (which got a massive cheer at the cinema) and heading north for the film's climax (think Home Alone cross-bred with Monarch of the Glen, directed by Michael Bay) set in the Bond family's ancestral Scottish home, which is, of course, called "Skyfall". In JB's absence the old pile has been looked after by an elderly, bearded, sarcastic scottish retainer, Kincade. Kincade is in fact played by the fabulous Albert Finney, but I rather shushpect that the role was offered to shomeone elshe firsht. We can only dream of how amazing that would have been, but if you can't get Connery, who better to hire instead than the man who once interrogated him in Murder on the Orient Express (I suspect that the antipathy between Finney's Poirot and Connery's Colonel Arbuthnot in that film had less to do with the murdered man in the next cabin and more to do with straightforward moustache envy!)
I will give no more away about how the film ends, but although it stays true to the series formula, unusually for Bond, there is more than one surprise in store. The whole thing from beginning to end feels like a Bond film made by Bond fans, for Bond fans. I don't mean that it is inaccessible to newcomers to the franchise, but it shows an understanding of the character's history which delighted me. I think that the Broccolis could do worse than lock Sam Mendes in for another few films, and Craig certainly has enough vim and verve in him for at least another two or three films (he may be craggy faced but he still has a few years in him before he turns into Sid James). His banter with Naomie Harris' Eve is particularly sparkling (the other Bond girl, Berenice Marlohe, was also perfectly fine but somewhat underused...to be honest at some points in the film I felt that the "real" Bond girl was Dame Judi).
Particular praise has to be reserved for Javier Bardem's villain though. The last few Bond villains have been lacklustre, to say the least. C'mon, Oddjob used to kill people with a steel rimmed bowler hat, Jaws used to bite people to death with his steel teeth and Le Chiffre...cries blood. Not quite in the same league, is it? Nor was Jonathan Pryce's slightly less evil version of Rupert Murdoch in Tomorrow Never Dies or that Korean bloke who plastic surgerifies himself into Toby Stephens in the risible Die Another Day. But Bardem as Silva is a revelation, playing a hypnotically charismatic, wickedly funny and extremely complex chessmaster who is constantly at least two steps ahead of Bond for most of the film in the same way that Blofeld and Goldfinger used to be. As viewers, we are simultaneously charmed by him and terrified of him. And he is also outrageously camp, taking the unconventional step of flirting with Bond rather than torturing him. Even more remarkably, Bond responds in kind. "What makes you think this is my first time?" he quips. One can only conclude that the two henchmen in Diamonds are Forever got closer to Bond than we thought. "If at first you don't succeed, Mr Kidd..." "Try, try, try again, Mr Wint!"
The film is not perfect. It is a little overlong for one thing, and for another, where did all that swearing suddenly come from? I am no prude, in fact my main criticism of the fourth Die Hard was that it didn't have enough swearing in it (as an aside, how can they keep making films in that franchise without taking the opportunity to call one of them "Old Habits Die Hard"...perhaps that one could be set in a nunnery with the tagline "Yippee Kiy Yay Mother Superior" and Bruce exchanging quips with rogue nun Miriam Margolyes...I'd watch it).
But this isn't Die Hard, it's Bond. I don't mind a bit of mild cursing here and there (Timothy Dalton used to snarl "bloody bastards" at random moments every once in a while, it was obviously something he needed to get out of his system and that was fine). I appreciate that it was about time that someone pointed out that Bond is in fact a "jumped up little shit" (because he is), and that Judi Dench dropping the F-bomb is always entertaining. As swearers go Dame Judi is up there with the best of them, and when she really gets going it is almost as good as Angela Lansbury's Tarantino-esque four letter rant in the uncut version of Bedknobs and Broomsticks. If you think Joe Pesci's "You think I'm funny" speech in Goodfellas was well delivered, just imagine Dench doing it. But I grew up watching the Sean/Roger films on ITV on a Sunday afternoon (there's nothing better than a good piece of family entertainment with a nice high bodycount). I just can't see the broadcasters allowing any of the Craig era Bond films to show pre-watershed, which is a shame. Of course this is nothing a bit of clever editing can't sort out (see here how they handled the swearing in The Big Lebowski for TV audiences), and if this is the worst I can find to say about the film I think it is an unequivocal sign of a job well done. I liked it. And I'm glad I liked it!
Right, that is all I have to say on that, but I quite enjoyed writing it, so the blog is officially back up and running. Reviews of The Hobbit and Les Mis will follow in due course, and there will be more posts in between if I can think of anything suitably interesting to ramble on about.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)